I want to present two hypothetical scenarios.

The first one involves a high school student who might be failing a class or two, or might have a discipline issue that is dealt with by school administration. The result could be in-school suspension, or detention, or something else.

The second one is a student with the same issues as the first — but he or she also is involved with a sports team or club. In this case the result might be an in-school suspension, or detention, or something else — in addition to not being allowed to participate in the sports or club activity until the grades improve.

This double punishment is a result of the so-called code of conduct that schools have in place.

When I went to school in the 1970s, no such code existed. In fact, not only was one expected to participate on sports teams, if you were unable to make the cut then intramural sports were offered as a substitute. And for good reason.

The benefits of being a part of a sports team are many. Along with exercise, it provides discipline, leadership, teamwork, game skills, structure and eliminating the idle time when teens often find themselves getting into trouble.

If schools actually want to “punish” a student, then maybe make them spend a week as part of a wrestling team’s practice. I guarantee they will never fail a course again.

That leads me to Nic Champion, a sophomore at Waterloo High School.

He played on the school’s junior varsity basketball team in 2016-17 and was a frequent contributor to the team effort both on offense and defense.

This year, his grades suffered, and he was declared ineligible. As expected, he was not permitted to play for the team.

However, after Nic’s grades improved to the satisfaction of the school, his coach refused to allow him back.

Nic’s dad, Ron, took the matter to the school’s Board of Education. By a vote of 7-1, Nic was allowed back on the team.

Since that decision every member of the team — there are 12 in all — has seen some playing time ... with the exception of Nic. This, even when the team had a double-digit lead in the fourth quarter. Nic is seated, at the far left, in the accompanying photo.

To Nic’s credit, he sits calmly on the bench awaiting his turn while encouraging his teammates throughout the game. I know because I went to watch a Waterloo game last week against Palmyra-Macedon.

The coach has been asked why Nic isn’t playing, and Ron said the coach’s responses to the family have been “Nic doesn’t know the plays,” “he shoots too much,” and “he doesn’t hustle.”

Ron claims he has an email from the varsity coach that says “Nic is a great basketball player.” He says he has a voice message from Athletic Director Jeff Panek saying “Nic is a very good player.”

Nic is 16. His dad worries about how this basketball experience, which Ron considers a form of bullying, will affect his child. Ron feels it is retaliation against Nic because Ron went to the school board on the matter. He feels the coach’s hope now is that Nic will become frustrated and quit the team.

Working through proper protocol, I asked Panek about the situation. Panek, whom I consider a friend, wasn’t interested in commenting on the issue other than to say he felt it wasn’t something that should be discussed in the newspaper.

Mark Salvatore Pitifer is a guidance counselor at Waterloo and one of the stronger advocates for children in our area. Also a friend of mine, he coaches track and field at Geneva High School and can be found at a Waterloo or Geneva sporting event most nights throughout the school year. He knows Nic well since he is part of Project HOPE — HOPE stands for Help Our Pupils Engage — a program Pitifer oversees at Waterloo. He feels what is happening to Nic on the basketball team is counterproductive for a kid trying to do the right thing.

Pitifer believes that for some academically challenged students, sports can be something that prevents them from giving up — and he feels strongly that no one at Waterloo or at any other public school should ever give up on any student.

When asked about his decision to comment for this piece, Pitifer’s reply was simple: “What’s right is right.”

Keep in mind that both sides were given the opportunity to tell their story, but only one did. That said, one hopes that Nic is able to find a good path in life as he matures and just maybe lives up to his surname.

In the meantime, in my opinion, it’s time to ask the coaches to be the grownups in this situation.

Recommended for you


(2) comments

Jacob W Hunt

The problem with the Waterloo Basketball program is exactly what you outlined (I'm paraphrasing here): "Grown ups need to act like grown ups."
My brother, Ethan Hunt, wasn't able to make the Basketball team this year because the coach that you mentioned in this article said that my brother was "out talented." Under normal circumstances, this wouldn't be a problem. If someone out performs another player because they worked harder in the off season to improve their game, then fair is fair. However, I don't believe this is the case.
Looking back at Ethan's career in Waterloo athletics, he's started for every Baseball team and Basketball team that he joined since entering the athletics programs. For the case of the Waterloo travel team for 5-6th graders, Ethan's uncles, Roger Hunt and Scott Hunt, coached the team. I know first hand that Roger and Scott treat each person on the team as players, and want them to prove themselves on the court before assigning them a starting role. However, take that explanation as you will. In the end, it is still a family relationship, despite Ethan's excellent performance in those years under their coaching. Looking at Ethan's baseball career, he's started on every team he's participated on. His coaches weren't related to him in any way, so the family member card can be taken off the table.
The main reason why I think that Ethan was cut from the team was because of this editorial that Corey Catholdi wrote in our local newspaper here in Waterloo. This isn't to say that Corey was to blame for any of this. His editorial is his opinion on the state of Waterloo High School's athletics program. However, in this editorial Corey praised Roger Hunt, Ethan's uncle, for being the best basketball coach in Waterloo. Here's a link to a picture of the piece that my mother took. The editorial is in the bottom left of the screen:
Take from this as you will. I believe this is a real problem in Waterloo's Basketball Athletics program. There needs to be some change in the way our coaches and Athletics Directors handle situations that occur outside of their department. When we have vendettas over editorials that cover someone's OPINION on Waterloo's Basketball programs that can directly affect the life of someone who wasn't involved, then we need to have a serious discussion on what the next steps should be.

Jacob W Hunt

I posted a status that contains the appropriate picture for the editorial.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.